Customer Testimonials | Real Stories, Real Impact

It [claims process] was great and [there was] no complications.

Pat Truckenmiller

Breakthrough Worship Center

Houses of Worship

For over 20 years we have been with Church Mutual. We left for a few years to save on premium but returned for the excellent customer service and overall value.

Paul VanCise

Bryant Wesleyan Church

Houses of Worship

In 2011 our church was struck by lightning and burned to the ground. Church Mutual worked with us from the day of the fire until the day we opened our new church three years later. They were extremely helpful. I highly recommend using them.

Rev. Dr. Bonnie Orth

Mayfield Presbyterian Church

Houses of Worship

We've only had three claims in 40 years of being insured by Church Mutual. The best way I would describe my experience with their handling of our claims speaks to the efficiency by which they responded. Their handling of our claims took the stress and worry out of the equation. Their representatives have always been pleasant to work with. I would not hesitate to recommend Church Mutual Ins.

Donald Pyle

The Church at Rockwood

Houses of Worship

They [Church Mutual] made the claim process very easy, [they] were very prompt, and took care of the the problem that we had.

Susan Tutor

St. Luke's Episcopal Church

Houses of Worship

Totally stress free, easy, [and] every contact was professional and a breeze.

Laura Gotcher

First United Methodist Chruch

Houses of Worship

I recently submitted a claim for lightning damage to our church. My contact was Ms. Sanderson. She is very knowledgeable, extremely helpful and a great customer service individual. She has changed my opinion of insurance companies completely. There are so many insurance companies that could take lessons from Church Mutual.

Ron Holcomb

La Grange First United Methodist Church

Houses of Worship

The handling of our hurricane claim, which occurred on 9/10/17, was handled superbly by Claim Manager, Lynn Renlund. Because of the lawsuit that was brought by the unscrupulous roofer & the subsequent lawsuit, her assistance was absolutely fantastic, and we are forever grateful. We were able to secure another roofer to make the repairs, which have now been completed.

Karen Marshall

Congregational Church of Mount Dora

Houses of Worship

Several times other companies have approached us with their proposals, but I told our Council members that your company has served us admirably for many years and there was no need to change now. Keep up the good work!!

Dean Carstensen

St. Timothy Lutheran Church

Houses of Worship

I have found that there are so many more resources available to us than at first believed. Very happy being associated with Church Mutual.

Michael Dacy

Valley View Baptist Church

Houses of Worship

Take the next step

We look forward to helping you protect your people, property and mission.

Prospective Customers

New to Church Mutual? Welcome! We’re excited to help you protect your people, property and mission. Simply enter your industry below to get started on a personalized quote.

My organization is a…

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Not ready for a quote, but have questions? Get In Touch

Existing Customers

If you’re an existing customer with a question about your policy, you’re in the right place. Find your local rep by entering a few details below.

Find your local representative

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Need to file a claim? File a Claim | Claims Center

Real Stories, Real Impact

Explore Testimonials

Share your experience

Take the next step

Prospective Customers

Existing Customers